State Tax & Housing Cost Comparison

Josh · Last updated:

Facts verified: against 1 source-backed data record; page sources include Source-tracked 2026 wage-income schedules; housing defaults are unverified illustrative planning inputs

Reviewed by Josh for financial modeling and data. See more by Josh.

A state with no wage income tax can still have a substantial property-tax bill. Enter your income and housing assumptions to compare the modeled costs side by side. Statewide property-tax and insurance figures are starting points; a particular home can differ considerably.

Home values, property-tax rates, insurance costs, and metro prices are illustrative planning inputs without an established source period. Replace them with the purchase price, a local tax estimate, and a current insurance quote.

Mortgage P&I uses 20% down, a 30-year term, and Freddie Mac’s 7.28% PMMS average from November 19, 2026. This benchmark is not a lender quote.

Your Numbers

Gross income before taxes - affects state income tax estimates

$

Home purchase price - affects property tax and insurance estimates

$

Property Tax vs. Income Tax by State

Each dot is a state. Bottom-left = lowest combined burden. Color reflects total monthly cost (green = cheapest, red = most expensive). Click to pin states for comparison.

Low cost
High cost

Lowest Total Cost

-

$0/mo

Highest Total Cost

-

$0/mo

Lowest Property Tax

-

0%

Lowest Income Tax

-

0%

All 50 States + DC Comparison

Click column headers to sort
State ↕ Property Tax ↕ Income Tax ↕ Insurance ↕ Mortgage P&I ↕ Total /mo ↕

Compare the same income and property value

The chart holds income and property value constant so you can see how modeled income tax, the property-tax planning rate and the insurance input affect the result. A top marginal income-tax rate is not the rate applied to every dollar. The dollar view uses each state's scoped single-filer schedule rather than multiplying income by its top rate.

What the housing inputs represent

Home values, property-tax rates, insurance costs, and metro prices are illustrative planning inputs without an established source period. Replace them with the purchase price, a local tax estimate, and a current insurance quote. The legacy home-value and metro fields are not verified sales-price medians. Local assessments, reassessment after a purchase, exemptions, coverage limits and separate hazard policies can change the amount a particular homeowner pays.

Insurance is a separate cost assumption

The stored Florida insurance input is $4,200/year and Utah's is $1,100/year. Those illustrative inputs produce a $258.333/month difference in this model. They are not comparable current quotes or verified state averages.

Federal deductions are outside this comparison

The ordinary 2026 SALT cap is $40,400, subject to filing-status and income rules. In an illustrative non-MFS case below the phase-down threshold with $50,000 of otherwise deductible state and local taxes, $9,600 lies above the cap. That does not itself determine a federal tax saving: itemizing status and the rest of the return still matter.

The income phase-down starts at $505,000 of MAGI for a non-MFS filer and reaches the $10,000 floor at about $606,334. The displayed state and housing totals do not subtract a modeled federal deduction benefit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which states have no modeled wage-income tax?
PennyCalc's 2026 wage-income schedules model no state wage-income tax in Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington and Wyoming. This does not mean every kind of income or every local tax is exempt. The housing columns use separate illustrative property-tax and insurance assumptions.
Are the property-tax and insurance figures current state averages?
Home values, property-tax rates, insurance costs, and metro prices are illustrative planning inputs without an established source period. Replace them with the purchase price, a local tax estimate, and a current insurance quote.
How does the SALT cap affect this comparison?
The ordinary 2026 SALT deduction cap is $40,400 ($20,200 for married filing separately). Above $505,000 of MAGI ($252,500 MFS), it falls by 30% of excess income, subject to a $10,000 floor ($5,000 MFS). The table shows costs before any federal itemized-deduction benefit.
Can this identify the cheapest state for my household?
It compares a scoped wage-income model and housing assumptions at the entered income and property value. It omits local income tax, many taxpayer-specific state adjustments, moving costs and many household expenses. Change the inputs and compare actual properties before treating a modeled ranking as a relocation decision.
Which mortgage and housing assumptions are included?
P&I assumes a 30-year loan with 20% down at Freddie Mac's 7.28% 30-year PMMS average from November 19, 2026. Each state's property-tax and insurance costs are illustrative planning inputs without a verified market observation period. HOA fees, maintenance, utilities, separate flood or earthquake coverage and closing costs are excluded. PMMS is a market benchmark, not a rate quote.

This calculator is for educational purposes. Income-tax estimates use the same source-reviewed 2026 single-filer wage-income schedules as the paycheck calculator; they are not fully filing-status-aware and do not reproduce every state credit, adjustment, or local tax. Property-tax and insurance defaults are illustrative planning inputs, not verified state medians or averages. Local income taxes are not included in this comparison. See the paycheck calculator for the supported local jurisdictions. Consult a tax professional for advice specific to your situation.