Compare the same income and property value
The chart holds income and property value constant so you can see how modeled income tax, the property-tax planning rate and the insurance input affect the result. A top marginal income-tax rate is not the rate applied to every dollar. The dollar view uses each state's scoped single-filer schedule rather than multiplying income by its top rate.
What the housing inputs represent
Home values, property-tax rates, insurance costs, and metro prices are illustrative planning inputs without an established source period. Replace them with the purchase price, a local tax estimate, and a current insurance quote. The legacy home-value and metro fields are not verified sales-price medians. Local assessments, reassessment after a purchase, exemptions, coverage limits and separate hazard policies can change the amount a particular homeowner pays.
Insurance is a separate cost assumption
The stored Florida insurance input is $4,200/year and Utah's is $1,100/year. Those illustrative inputs produce a $258.333/month difference in this model. They are not comparable current quotes or verified state averages.
Federal deductions are outside this comparison
The ordinary 2026 SALT cap is $40,400, subject to filing-status and income rules. In an illustrative non-MFS case below the phase-down threshold with $50,000 of otherwise deductible state and local taxes, $9,600 lies above the cap. That does not itself determine a federal tax saving: itemizing status and the rest of the return still matter.
The income phase-down starts at $505,000 of MAGI for a non-MFS filer and reaches the $10,000 floor at about $606,334. The displayed state and housing totals do not subtract a modeled federal deduction benefit.